Call (703) 880-8412Latest updatesContact us

Employment tax · 1099 vs W-2 · Worker classification

1099 or W-2? Get worker classification right before the IRS or Virginia decides for you.

Treating employees as independent contractors can cost years of payroll taxes, penalties and, in Virginia, separate state fines. We review your workforce under the IRS, Department of Labor and Virginia rules, fix problems through the right relief program, and defend you in classification audits and Tax Court.

Forms & standards
IRC § 3121(d)Rev. Rul. 87-41Section 530 reliefForm 8952 (VCSP)Form SS-8IRC § 7436Va. Code § 58.1-1900

Serving United States, Virginia, Washington, DC, Maryland.

What we handle

Three sets of rules, one workforce

For federal employment taxes, the IRS applies the common-law test: does the business have the right to control what work is done and how it is done? The IRS groups the evidence into behavioral control, financial control and the relationship of the parties, and the Tax Court weighs factors such as control, investment, opportunity for profit or loss, the right to discharge, whether the work is part of the regular business, and permanence. Doubtful cases are resolved in favor of employment.

Wage and hour law uses a separate economic-reality test. In February 2026 the Department of Labor proposed replacing its 2024 six-factor rule with a test centered on two core factors, control and opportunity for profit or loss; as of mid-2026 that rule was still a proposal. Virginia adds its own layer: since 2020 a worker paid for services is presumed to be an employee unless the business shows contractor status under IRS guidelines, with civil penalties of up to $1,000, $2,500 and $5,000 per misclassified worker for first, second and later offenses, and possible debarment from public contracts.

Speak with an advisor
  • Workforce classification reviewEach worker group tested under the IRS, DOL and Virginia standards, with a written conclusion.
  • Section 530 relief analysisWhether you meet the reporting consistency, substantive consistency and reasonable basis requirements.
  • Voluntary Classification Settlement ProgramForm 8952 filings to reclassify workers prospectively, generally paying 10% of one year's reduced liability with no interest or penalties.
  • Form SS-8 determinationsPreparing or responding to IRS determination requests.
  • IRS employment tax auditsRepresentation from the first document request through the Notice of Determination.
  • Tax Court petitionsSupport for counsel in section 7436 cases, which must be filed within 90 days of the notice.
  • Virginia Department of Taxation and VECResponding to state misclassification inquiries and unemployment insurance audits.
  • Contracts and onboardingContractor agreements, invoices, insurance and records that support independent status.

Where we help

Recent Tax Court cases

2022

Pediatric Impressions Home Health v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2022-35

A home health agency switched about 99 nurses from W-2 to 1099 in 2016. The court held they were employees, denied Section 530 relief because the agency had treated similar nurses as employees before, and upheld all penalties.

2023

Cardiovascular Center v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2023-64

A medical practice paid its office manager and medical assistants hourly from approved timesheets labeled employees. The court held they were employees and denied Section 530 relief.

2025

Belagio Fine Jewelry v. Commissioner, 164 T.C. No. 7

The 90-day deadline to petition the Tax Court in a classification case can be equitably tolled, but the facts did not justify it, so the late petition failed.

2020

Reflectxion Resources v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2020-114

A medical staffing agency could contest classification and Section 530 relief only for quarters where an actual controversy existed, not for quarters it had already reported the therapists as employees.

Our approach

How the engagement runs.

Inventory

List every worker paid on Form 1099 and how each is engaged, supervised and paid.

Test

Apply the IRS, DOL and Virginia standards and rank the risk by group.

Correct

Choose the path: keep with stronger documentation, reclassify, or use VCSP.

Defend

Represent the business in IRS, Department of Labor and Virginia audits.

Questions

Frequently asked

If your question isn't here, call (703) 880-8412 and you'll reach a person.

What is the difference between a 1099 contractor and a W-2 employee?

An employee works under the business's right to direct and control the work; the business withholds income tax, pays employer FICA and FUTA and issues Form W-2. An independent contractor runs a separate business, controls how the work is done, bears profit or loss and receives Form 1099-NEC.

What is Section 530 relief?

A statutory safe harbor that can stop federal employment taxes for workers treated as contractors if the business filed all required 1099s, treated similar workers consistently, and had a reasonable basis such as court precedent, a prior IRS audit or long-standing industry practice.

What does VCSP cost?

Under the Voluntary Classification Settlement Program, an eligible business that agrees to treat the workers as employees going forward generally pays 10% of the employment tax liability computed under the reduced rates of section 3509 for the most recent tax year, with no interest or penalties and no employment tax audit of prior years for those workers.

Does Virginia have its own misclassification rules?

Yes. Since 2020 Virginia presumes a paid worker is an employee unless IRS guidelines show otherwise, lets misclassified workers sue for lost wages and benefits, protects workers who report misclassification, and lets the Department of Taxation impose penalties and debar repeat offenders from public contracts.

Is the Department of Labor test the same as the IRS test?

No. The DOL applies an economic-reality test for minimum wage and overtime. Its February 2026 proposal would focus on control and opportunity for profit or loss, but a worker can be an employee under one law and not another, so each test must be checked.

Can nurses and therapists be independent contractors?

Sometimes, for example a clinician with an established practice who sets fees and works for several facilities. But when the agency sets schedules and rates, can discipline or remove the worker, and the work is the agency's core business, courts usually find employment, as in Pediatric Impressions Home Health.

Latest updates

IRS & federal tax

All IRS & federal tax updates
Nov 5, 2026IRS & federal tax

IRS releases 2027 inflation adjustments (Rev. Proc. 2026-35)

For 2027 the joint-return standard deduction rises to $33,200, the estate tax basic exclusion to $15,480,000, the annual gift exclusion to $20,000 and the Section 179 expensing limit to $2,640,000. Our advisors recommend revisiting year-end gifting and equipment purchase plans with these figures in mind.

Source: IRS (IR-2026-133)

Our guidance

Start a conversation

Have a notice, a deadline or a deal on the table?

Tell us what you're facing. A senior advisor will reply within one business day with a clear next step.