Our view: Real for businesses that use the equipment. Packaged passive programs often deliver less.
How it works
In a typical program, an investor buys revenue-producing equipment, mostly with financing, while a third party operates it. The investor plans to deduct the full cost in year one. Several rules can change that result:
- Passive-loss rules. If someone else runs the activity, the loss usually offsets only passive income, not salary or active business income.
- At-risk rules. Losses are limited to the cash and debt you are personally on the hook for.
- Ownership. Arrangements that look more like a financing than a purchase can lose the depreciation entirely.
- Recapture. At sale, prior depreciation is generally taxed as ordinary income.
- State tax. Several states, including Virginia, do not allow federal bonus depreciation.
Hypothetical example
A CEO puts $250,000 down on $1.2 million of financed equipment managed by an operator. The projection shows a large first-year tax saving. But he does not materially participate, so the loss is passive. He has little passive income, so the deduction carries forward unused. When the equipment is sold in year five, the recapture is taxed as ordinary income, and most of the sale price goes to repay the loan.
How a CEO should decide
Ask whether you would buy this equipment as a business owner, with its real revenue and resale risk, if there were no tax benefit. Then have your CPA test the passive-loss, at-risk and recapture rules against your own return.


