Call (703) 880-8412Latest updatesContact us

CEO decision guide · 09 of 10

Micro-Captive Insurance

Captive insurance can serve a real risk-management purpose, mainly for larger companies with risks the commercial market won't cover well. Small captives marketed mainly as a tax deduction are, in our view, high risk.

Our view: High risk when tax-driven. 2025 listed-transaction rules and a long record of court losses.

How it works

A business forms its own insurance company, which elects to be taxed only on its investment income (IRC §831(b)). The operating company deducts the premiums it pays to the captive.

  • Disclosure rules. Under IRS regulations issued in January 2025, certain micro-captive arrangements are listed transactions and others are transactions of interest, both requiring disclosure.
  • Court record. Courts have repeatedly held that poorly designed captives were not real insurance, for example Avrahami v. Commissioner (2017) and Reserve Mechanical Corp. v. Commissioner (10th Cir. 2022).

Hypothetical example

A company pays its captive large premiums each year, the captive pays almost no claims, and the money comes back to the owners as loans. If examined, the IRS may treat the premiums as nondeductible and assert penalties. That is the pattern courts have rejected.

How a CEO should decide

Start with the risk, not the deduction. If you cannot name the specific uninsured risks the captive covers, or the premiums are set to hit a target deduction, walk away.

CEO checklist

Ask these before you sign

Bring the answers, and the offering documents, to your CPA.

  • What specific risks does the captive cover that commercial insurance does not?
  • Are premiums set by an independent actuary?
  • What claims have been paid relative to premiums?
  • Will any captive funds come back to the business or owners as loans?
  • Is the arrangement a listed transaction or transaction of interest under the 2025 rules?

This content is general educational information prepared by VG CPA PC and reflects our general views. It is not tax, legal or investment advice, and it is not a recommendation to buy or avoid any investment. It does not describe or evaluate any specific offering, sponsor, product or presentation. All examples are hypothetical and simplified for illustration. Tax results depend on each taxpayer's facts, and on federal and state law that can change. Our view of any specific transaction may differ once we review the actual offering documents, appraisals, tax opinions and your personal tax situation. Consult a qualified tax advisor before acting.

The full CEO framework and 10-question checklistRelated: IRS Audit Representation

Free CEO tool · 2 minutes

The CEO Tax Strategy Checklist

Offered a year-end tax strategy? Answer 10 questions and see the red flags before you sign.

Start the CEO checklist

Start a conversation

Weighing this strategy?

Send us the proposal. A senior advisor will reply within one business day with what it means for your return.

CallContact us
Text us