Call (703) 880-8412Latest updatesContact us

CEO decision guide · 08 of 10

Donation Programs Involving Bulk-Purchased Property

Buying property at a deep discount and donating it at a much higher "retail," "list" or "appraised" value is one of the oldest charitable tax shelter patterns. We believe it should be avoided. The IRS and the courts have rejected it for more than 40 years.

Our view: Avoid. The IRS and the courts have rejected this pattern for more than 40 years.

How it works

Investors fund an entity that buys goods, collectibles or similar items in bulk. The entity then donates them, claiming a deduction based on a much higher value. Public law to know:

  • Short holding period. Property held one year or less is generally deductible only at cost (IRC §170(e)(1)(A)).
  • Price paid sets the value. The IRS has long held that the price actually paid in a bulk purchase is the best evidence of value, not a promoter's retail figure (Rev. Rul. 80-69; Rev. Rul. 80-233). Courts agree, for example Anselmo v. Commissioner (11th Cir. 1985).
  • Bulk discount. A large quantity is not worth the sum of single-item retail prices.
  • Related use. Tangible property is deductible at fair market value only if the charity uses it in its exempt purpose. Otherwise the deduction is generally limited to cost.
  • Penalties. Overvaluation penalties of 40% can apply, without a reasonable-cause defense.

Hypothetical example

A CEO pays $40,000 into a program that buys goods at a steep discount and donates them at a "list price" of $160,000. Because the goods were held less than a year and anyone could buy them at the discounted price, the IRS limits the deduction to cost. Her actual tax saving is a fraction of the $40,000 she paid, and she owes penalties on the overstated amount.

How a CEO should decide

Charitable giving should cost you money; that is what makes it a gift. Any program where the donor "comes out ahead" because of the tax deduction deserves serious skepticism.

CEO checklist

Ask these before you sign

Bring the answers, and the offering documents, to your CPA.

  • What did the entity pay for the property, and when?
  • Could anyone buy the same items at that price?
  • Is the claimed value based on list or retail prices rather than actual sales?
  • Will the charity use the property in its mission, or sell it?
  • Am I told I will "net" a gain from the donation?
  • Will the sponsor indemnify me for tax, penalties and interest in writing?

This content is general educational information prepared by VG CPA PC and reflects our general views. It is not tax, legal or investment advice, and it is not a recommendation to buy or avoid any investment. It does not describe or evaluate any specific offering, sponsor, product or presentation. All examples are hypothetical and simplified for illustration. Tax results depend on each taxpayer's facts, and on federal and state law that can change. Our view of any specific transaction may differ once we review the actual offering documents, appraisals, tax opinions and your personal tax situation. Consult a qualified tax advisor before acting.

The full CEO framework and 10-question checklist

Free CEO tool · 2 minutes

The CEO Tax Strategy Checklist

Offered a year-end tax strategy? Answer 10 questions and see the red flags before you sign.

Start the CEO checklist

Start a conversation

Weighing this strategy?

Send us the proposal. A senior advisor will reply within one business day with what it means for your return.

CallContact us
Text us