Call (703) 880-8412Latest updatesContact us

Tax strategy · November 2026

How CEOs Should Evaluate a Tax Strategy Before Signing

Business owners are offered tax strategies all year, most often in the last quarter. Some use long-standing provisions of the tax code exactly as Congress intended. Others are built to produce a deduction first and a business reason second. From the outside, the two can look alike.

A good tax strategy is a good business or investment decision first. The tax benefit should improve a sound decision, never justify a weak one.

This series explains how we think about the strategies CEOs ask us about most, and gives you a checklist you can use before you sign anything.

Three principles every CEO should apply

1. Be cautious when the deduction is bigger than the check. When a strategy promises a deduction several times the cash you invest in the same year, ask a simple question: why is this property worth so much more on my tax return than it cost a few weeks ago? For decades, the courts have generally held that a recent arm's-length purchase price is the best evidence of value.

2. Separate permanent savings from timing. Many strategies defer tax rather than remove it. Depreciation, deferral elections and similar benefits often reverse later through recapture or a recognition date, sometimes as ordinary income and sometimes when the deal produces no cash to pay it. Always model the exit, not just year one.

3. Remember who carries the risk. If the IRS disallows a benefit, the investor pays the tax, interest and penalties, which commonly run from 20% to 40% of the underpayment. An opinion letter does not always protect you. For overvalued gifts of property, the law removes the usual reasonable-cause defense for the largest penalty.

The CEO checklist

10 questions before you sign

Our rule of thumb: A "yes" to the first question or a "no" to the second means slow down and get an independent review.

  • Is the deduction or loss larger than the cash I am investing this year?
  • Would I make this investment if the tax benefit were zero?
  • How much of my dollar reaches the actual asset or charitable purpose, after fees and commissions?
  • Is this a "listed transaction" or "transaction of interest" that I must disclose to the IRS?
  • Do the passive-loss, at-risk or excess-business-loss rules limit my deduction?
  • Does my state follow the federal rule?
  • When the benefit reverses, what will I owe, and where will the cash come from?
  • Who selected and paid the appraiser and opinion writer, and can I read their full reports first?
  • How have the sponsor's earlier transactions fared under IRS examination?
  • Will the sponsor indemnify me in writing for tax, penalties, interest and defense costs?

Free CEO tool · 2 minutes

The CEO Tax Strategy Checklist

Offered a year-end tax strategy? Answer 10 questions and see the red flags before you sign.

Start the CEO checklist

Our strategy guides

Ten strategies, one page each.

Each guide covers what we believe, how the strategy works, a hypothetical example, how a CEO should decide, and a checklist.

How we help

VG CPA PC is independent. We are not compensated by investment sponsors, so our only goal is to show what a proposal does on your return, net of fees, state tax and future recapture. If you are considering a strategy, share the offering documents with us before you commit.

Call (703) 880-8412 or email info@vgcpapc.com.

This content is general educational information prepared by VG CPA PC and reflects our general views. It is not tax, legal or investment advice, and it is not a recommendation to buy or avoid any investment. It does not describe or evaluate any specific offering, sponsor, product or presentation. All examples are hypothetical and simplified for illustration. Tax results depend on each taxpayer's facts, and on federal and state law that can change. Our view of any specific transaction may differ once we review the actual offering documents, appraisals, tax opinions and your personal tax situation. Consult a qualified tax advisor before acting.

Start a conversation

Considering a strategy before year-end?

Send us the offering documents before you commit. A senior advisor will show you what it does on your return, net of fees, state tax and recapture.

CallContact us
Text us