A good tax strategy is a good business or investment decision first. The tax benefit should improve a sound decision, never justify a weak one.
This series explains how we think about the strategies CEOs ask us about most, and gives you a checklist you can use before you sign anything.
Three principles every CEO should apply
1. Be cautious when the deduction is bigger than the check. When a strategy promises a deduction several times the cash you invest in the same year, ask a simple question: why is this property worth so much more on my tax return than it cost a few weeks ago? For decades, the courts have generally held that a recent arm's-length purchase price is the best evidence of value.
2. Separate permanent savings from timing. Many strategies defer tax rather than remove it. Depreciation, deferral elections and similar benefits often reverse later through recapture or a recognition date, sometimes as ordinary income and sometimes when the deal produces no cash to pay it. Always model the exit, not just year one.
3. Remember who carries the risk. If the IRS disallows a benefit, the investor pays the tax, interest and penalties, which commonly run from 20% to 40% of the underpayment. An opinion letter does not always protect you. For overvalued gifts of property, the law removes the usual reasonable-cause defense for the largest penalty.



